Back to All stories
Analytics cohorts

Retention curves, explained

The single most useful chart in product analytics is also one of the most misread. How to build a retention curve, what its shape tells you and the mistakes that make it lie.

(Words)

Retention curves that fall steeply and then level off
Retention curves that fall steeply and then level off

What it is

A retention curve groups customers by when they started — a cohort — and shows what share of each cohort is still active in each period afterwards. Week zero is always one hundred percent. Every point after that answers one question: of the people who started then, how many are still here now?

Reading the shape

Almost every curve falls steeply at first. The question that matters is whether it flattens. A curve that levels off means some share of customers has found lasting value; the height of that plateau is the size of your retained base. A curve that keeps falling toward zero means the product has not yet found a group of customers who need it repeatedly, however good the acquisition numbers look.

Common curve shapes and what to do with each.
ShapeWhat it usually meansWhere to look next
Steep drop, then flatA core of retained customersRaise the plateau: activation and early habit
Steady decline to zeroNo durable value yetWho stays longest, and why
Flat, then risingCustomers returning or expandingWhich behavior predicts the return
Newer cohorts higherRecent changes are workingConfirm the cause before you scale it

Defining active

The curve is only as honest as your definition of active. Logging in is a weak definition; a customer can open the app, see nothing useful and leave. Choose the action that represents value — sending an invoice, completing a lesson, placing an order — and count that.

Choose the period to match natural use, too. A daily-use messaging tool should be measured by day or week; an accounting product used at month end needs a monthly curve, or it will look like it is failing every week.

Warning

The averaging trap

A single blended retention number across all customers hides everything. Mixing old, loyal cohorts with new ones makes retention look stable while each new cohort is doing worse. Always compare cohorts side by side.

Common mistakes

Reading the right-hand edge of young cohorts as if it were final. Comparing cohorts acquired through very different channels without separating them. And celebrating a lift in week one that disappears by week six — the classic signature of a campaign, not a change in behavior.

How many customers do I need in a cohort?
Enough that a few people leaving doesn’t swing the line. With very small cohorts, group by month instead of by week, and treat the curve as directional.
What is a good retention rate?
It depends heavily on the product category and pricing model. Your own cohorts over time are a far better benchmark than an industry average.

For pitches, data you would like us to look at and letters to the editor, write to us any time. We read everything.

Free. One study, one teardown and one thing to test, every Tuesday morning. Nothing else.

(The Tuesday brief)